|

Objectives: This course provides the student with an overview of the major theological/philosophical
principles employed by bioethicists and application of these principles to important cases. We will discuss cases and
current issues in bioethics in light of the Christian (Catholic) tradition. Central to our reflection will be how current
practices affecting human life and health are consistent with humans being created in the image of God. At
the end of the course, students will be able to understand, use and apply
appropriate ethical principles to various issues in bioethics
This course is just the beginning, and it is my intention to acquaint you with the major principles, issues and
resources in bioethics. We will also be examining attitudes, which shape the context for bioethical decisions in light
of the Christian tradition.
Texts: First Do No
Harm --Lisa Belkin. New York: Fawcett Crest, 1994.
Contemporary
Catholic Health Care Ethics - David F. Kelly. Washington DC: Georgetown
University Press, 2004.
There are also a number of required articles on the course web site.
Recommended:
Ethics of Health Care. 3rd Ed. Benedict Ashley and Kevin O'Rourke.
Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press, 2002.
Contemporary Issues in
Bioethics: A Catholic Perspective. James J, Walter and Thomas A. Shannon.
Lantham, MD: Rowman and Litttlefield, 2005.
Health Care Ethics: Theological Foundations, Contemporary Issues and
Controversial Cases. Panicola, Belde, et al. Winona, MN: Saint Mary Press,
2008.
| You
here to see the current web site for Hermann
Hospital in Houston, Texas. This is the Hospital that we are reading about in Lisa Belkin's book
First Do No Harm. |
There are many good resources on the links page. Also, our library has a pretty good collection of books in
bioethics/healthcare ethics under the call letters R724-6.
Requirements: There will be a reflection paper,
a bibliography, a short research paper
on a bioethical issue and an ethics committee simulation.. You should follow a
style guide (MLA, Chicago) and be consistent when writing papers. You can
consult The Everyday Writer, the writing handbook that is used for Core as well
as links on my web site for formatting questions.. I do look at issues of
formatting in papers. Additionally, EBSCO will give the proper formatting for
bibliographic entries. Late papers will be docked points.
There will also be three exams. Exams are usually short answer and essays. We also
will be doing an ethics committee simulation, wherein you will be taking on the role of some one on an ethics
committee.
Special Needs: If you are a student with special needs, please see me privately sometime before the third
week of the semester, so that arrangements can be made to facilitate your learning needs.
Honesty: The papers, exams, and assignment are to be your work. Plagiarism in any form will not be
tolerated. The penalty for this, or any infraction of the "Academic Honesty Policy" of the College (see Catalog,
pp.53-4) will be at the minimum an "F" for the assignment, and a report filed with the Dean.
I also expect students to attend class and to participate in discussions. You may have
one unexcused absences,
with no penalty. More than two unexcused absences will result in a full letter grade reduction. More than
three unexcused absences will result in a failing grade!

Class Calendar
The online articles are available only to
SJC students on campus network.
(The online readings are
under construction 1-2-09, but dates are now correct 1-5-09)
|
January
|
|
5 -
Intro |
12 -
Stories from the Front Lines
Belkin, pp.3-159 & Kelly
"Ethics Committees" pp. 229-244 |
19 -
More stories
Belkin, pp. 160-349
|
| 26 -
Kelly, "Theological Basis" pp. 1-47 (Reaction
Paper) |
|
February
|
|
2 -
Kelly, "Method" pp. 51-87 EXAM |
9 -
Kelly "Method" (cont'd) Birth Control pp. 88-123
 | Smugar, Steven, Spina, Bernadette, Metz, Jon. "Informed
Consent for Emergency Contraception: Variability in Hospital Care of
Rape Victims." American Journal of Public Health;
Sep 2000, Vol. 90 Issue 9, p1372-7. |
 | Hamel, PhD, Ronald P., & Michael R.
Panicola, PhD. "Emergency
Contraception and Sexual Assault." Health Progress,
September-October, 2002 Volume 83, Number 5.
Recommended |
 | Paul VI Humanae
Vitae. (1968) |
|
| 16-
Kelly,
"Applications" Ordinary & Extraordinary Means pp. 127-33
|
| 23-
Kelly, "Applications" Killing & Allowing to Die pp. 134-42
(Bibliography due)
|
|
Spring
Break
|
|
March
|
9
-
Kelly,
"Applications" Surrogate Decision-Making pp. 143-169
 | Shepard, Randall T. "Family
decision-making and forgoing treatment: A judicial perspective."
Issues in Law & Medicine; Winter94, Vol. 10 Issue 3,
p251, 10p. |
 | Porter, Theresa, Johnson, Punporn, Warren,
Nancy. "Bioethical
Issues Concerning Death." Critical Care Nursing
Quarterly; Jan-Mar2005, Vol. 28 Issue 1, p85-92.
|
|
16- Kelly "Applications" Advanced Directives & Nutrition
& Hydration pp. 170-195
EXAM
Required
 | Address of John Paul II to the Participants in
the International Congress on "Life
Sustaining Treatments and Vegetative State: Scientific Advances and
Ethical Dilemmas". Saturday, 20 March 2004 |
 | Repenshek, Mark, Slosar, John Paul
"Medically
Assisted Nutrition and Hydration: A Contribution to the Dialogue."
Hastings Center Report; Nov/Dec2004, Vol. 34 Issue 6, p13-16. |
 | Sulmasy, Daniel. "Terri
Schaivo and the Roman Catholic Tradition of Forgoing Extraordinary
Means of Care." Journal of Law, Medicine &
Ethics; Summer 2005, Vol. 33 Issue 2, p359-362.
|
 | Cheryl Arenella MD, MPH, Artificial
Nutrition and Hydration: Beneficial or Harmful? America Hospice
Foundation, 2005. |
 | The
Patient Self-Determination Act (1992) |
Recommended
 | Barry, Robert. "The
Papal Allocution on Caring for Persons in a "Vegetative
State"." Issues in Law & Medicine 20, no. 2
(Fall2004 2004): 155-164. |
 | Fins, Joseph J. "Rethinking
Disorders of Consciousness: New Research and Its Implications."
Hastings Center Report; Mar/Apr2005, Vol. 35 Issue 2, p22-24. |
 | Shannon, Thomas A., Walter, James J.
"Assisted
Nutrition and Hydration and the Catholic
Tradition" Theological Studies, Sep. 2005, Vol. 66,
Issue 3. |
 | Hamel, Ronald, Panicola,
Michael. "Must
We Preserve Life?" America; 4/19/2004, Vol. 190
Issue 14, p6-13. |
 | Sieger, Carol, Arnold, Jason, Ahronheim,
Judith. "Refusing
Artificial Nutrition and Hydration: Does Statutory Law Send the
Wrong Message?" Journal of the American Geriatrics
Society; Mar2002, Vol. 50 Issue 3, p544-550.
|
|
| 23-
Kelly,
"Applications" Physician Assisted Suicide/Medical Futility pp.
196-219
Required
 | Amundson, Ron, Taira, Gayle. "The
Effect of Life Experience on the Perceived Morality of the Policy of
Physician-Assisted Suicide." Journal of Disability
Policy Studies; Summer 2005, Vol. 16 Issue 1, p53-57, 5p. |
 | Engelhardt, H. Tristram, Smith Iltis, Ana.
"End-of-life:
the traditional Christian view." Lancet; 9/17/2005,
Vol. 366 Issue 9490, p1045-1049, 5p. |
 | Pearlman, Robert A., et. al. "Motivations
for Physician-assisted Suicide." Journal of General
Internal Medicine; Mar2005, Vol. 20 Issue 3, p234-239, 6p. |
 | Stevens Jr., Kenneth R. "Emotional
and Psychological Effects of Physician-Assisted Suicide and
Euthanasia on Participating Physicians." Issues in Law
& Medicine 21, no. 3 (Spring2006 2006): 187-200. |
 | AMA position on Physician
Assisted Suicide |
Recommended
 | Winenerg, Howard, Werth, James L. "Physician-Assisted
Suicide in Oregon: What are the Key Factors?". Death
Studies; Jul2003, Vol. 27 Issue 6, p501, 18p |
 | Starks, Helene, Anthony L. Back, Robert A.
Pearlman, Barbara A. Koenig, Clarissa Hsu, Judith R. Gordon, and
Ashok J. Bharucha. 2007. "Family
Member Involvement in Hastened Death." Death Studies 31,
no. 2: 105-13. |
 | Gentzler, Jyl. "What
is a Death With Dignity?" Journal of Medicine &
Philosophy; Aug 2003, Vol. 28 Issue 4, p461-487, 27p. |
|
30- Kelly, "Applications" Pain Management pp. 220-228
Ethics Committee Simulation
 | Chrystal-Frances, Eileen. "Palliative
Care: A Discussion of Management and Ethical Issues."
Nursing Forum; Apr-Jun2003, Vol. 38 Issue 2, p25, 4. |
 | "California
Law Requires Physician Education in Pain Management, End-of-Life
Care." Journal of Hospice & Palliative Nursing
4, no. 1 (January 2002): 14. |
 | Hoffmann, Diane E. "Pain
Management and Palliative Care in the Era of Managed Care: Issues
for Health Insurers." Journal of Law, Medicine &
Ethics; Winter98, Vol. 26 Issue 4, p267, 23p.
|
|
|
April
|
6
- Kelly,
"Applications" Stem Cells/Genetic Engineering pp. 245-269
 | "Genetic
Embryo Screening" Chicago Tribune (3-26-09)
See also the related article. |
 | Childress, James F. "Human
Cloning and Human Dignity: The Report of the President's Council on
Bioethics." Hastings Center Report; May/Jun2003,
Vol. 33 Issue 3, p15-18. |
 | Dresser, Rebecca. "Designing
Babies: Human Research Issues." IRB: Ethics & Human
Research; Sep/Oct2004, Vol. 26 Issue 5, p1-8. |
 | Elster, Nanette. "Assisted
Reproductive Technologies: Contracts, Consents, and Controversies."
American Journal of Family Law; Winter2005, Vol. 18 Issue 4,
p193-199. |
 | McKibben, Bill., Kraft, Stephanie. "Design-a-kid."
Christian Century; 5/17/2003, Vol. 120 Issue 10, p22-9. |
Recommended
|
| 13
- No Class (Easter) |
| 20
- Kelly, "Applications" Allocations Arguments pp.
270-296 Paper
Due
Organ Donation
Recommended:
|
|
27
Final Exam 6:30 PM
|
Go to Top | Bioethics Links |
Bioethics Updates | St. Joseph's College |
McFarland Home

Page updated 04/09/2009 by
T. McFarland, C.PP.S. Assoc. Prof. of Religion
Saint Joseph's College.
Questions of comments about this page -- email timm@saintjoe.edu |